In very broad terms, Scotland has five golf playing regions (arguably a sixth with western isles and highlands). Ireland has three, (arguably a fourth but the north west remains largely undiscovered).
Some regions support a better non-golf complement than others. In Scotland that means Edinburgh (Muirfield & North Berwick) the Highlands (Dornoch & Castle Stuart), and Fife (St Andrews & Carnoustie) are particularly good. Aberdeenshire and Ayrshire are strong for golf but weaker for non-golf.
In Ireland, the Antrim Coast (Giants Causeway) with Portrush is strong. Dublin can always be combined with Portmarnock and is often a cheaper trans-Atlantic flight so worth considering, if only for 48 hrs. West Ireland (Ballybunion and Lahinch) isn’t weak, but we do have to reach to find the interest
There are also opportunities in what we would describe as ‘line of travel’ driving where golfers can take the lead and the non-golf effectively comes to all of us
Golf Courses that have credible non-golf offers in very close proximity include
Although this is not an exclusive list, some of the more obvious ones include:
Dublin and Belfast are better hubs to pivot off than Shannon and Cork. This means that itineraries which seek to combine Scotland with west Ireland can be a little bit more difficult to stitch together. The bigger question we probably need to answer though is what appetite exists amongst non-golfers for undertaking some independent self-driving? Some will, but most are reluctant to do so
Whereas the correlation between golf and non-golf is often quite strong, local mileage between a golf course and a visitor destination still needs plugging. We can often operate a drop-off, (golfers) drive-on (non-golfers) and return to pick up model. If the visitor attraction concerned is particularly time consuming, we can sometimes reverse this and ask the golfers to perform the task
Edinburgh and Dublin are two destinations where we can usually rely public transport instead. St Andrews and Stirling are small enough for a non-golfer to ‘get away with’ not driving too. Outside of this, the reluctant non-golfer will usually hire a driving guide to cover the gaps they don’t fancy doing. This can become expensive however if we come to rely on it. We need to use this approach discriminatorily
This is largely about cost. Transport provided by hired drivers/ driver guides is a reasonably static cost divided by the number of people who are able to burden share it for a price per person. In very simple terms, the more non-golfers we have, the cheaper it becomes and the more hired drive solutions we can probably consider (assuming that there is a financial boundary somewhere).
Smaller parties can always consider hiring a supporting car to operate alongside a nine-seater MPV. Sometimes the objection can be about vehicle familiarity (although you might argue that the larger MPV also has an enforcing quality about it as other motorists tend to give way to it!). We’d normally need to use an MPV however as soon as we hit two golfers and two non-golfers (six luggage items) so its quite a low bar, although we could also operate two saloon cars on that manifest too if we preferred
We only really require there to be one reasonably confident non-golfer in a party however for a lot of these considerations be solved
Almost by necessity, any Scottish/ Irish combination has to route through one of Dublin or Edinburgh, and quite probably both, after all, both capitals are legitimate non-golf draws. This means we’ll be faced with at least one major retail city and quite probably more. We’ll also have the golf angle covered with the numerous trade shops of St Andrews, plus a host of craft shops which would be more prevalent around Scotland perhaps than they would be Ireland
Much of the rationale for retail applies to restaurants as well. Both Dublin and Edinburgh benefit for international influences and scale
St Andrews is strong due in no small part to the amount of money that a golf industry can attract
On balance, the Scottish offer is probably better than Ireland’s as it has a stronger base associated with game and salmon, whereas both destinations have a tradition for fish
Neither Scotland or Ireland could be described as tropical by even the most optimistic of travel agents, but they do offer a family looking for a beach holiday some comfort. Portmarnock is a beach resort just north of Dublin, and Newcastle (Royal County Down) is also beach destination. Much to many people’s surprise, St Andrews also has two sandy beaches. The most beachy holiday destination that supports golf would be Troon, and it would be worth noting that North Berwick also has a perfectly adequate beach as well. What all lack of course is a hot climate
If our interest lies more in outdoor activities then Scotland is better geared up than Ireland as its highlands, particularly the area around Aviemore, support a whole host of outdoor family activities. What we typically see families do in situations like this is establish a base there, and then make the golfer(s) do the mileage
Neither Ireland nor Scotland has a particularly good rail network but that’s not to say it can’t selectively be put to use
To make Scotland work though, we probably need to radiate out from Edinburgh. Both Stirling and Glasgow are relatively easy to add for a non-golfer
There are a couple of more ambitious options that are often overlooked because they involve crossing the border, but the northern English cities of Durham and York would fall within day-trip range of the Scottish capital
We don't need to make this an ordeal by 101 filtering questions! In reality there are probably little more than half a dozen things we need to know to build out a proposal. The guidance below might help you frame answers
Duration - usually best expressed as a range up to a maximum
Time of year - can be anything from a specific date range to a named season
Travel class - Faraway Fairways uses 'Luxury', 'Premier' or 'Affordable' for generic purposes. You might choose to reference the international 'star' rating system. We're only looking for something to help steer us into the right sector
Self drive or hired driver - In broad terms, self driving is normally less expensive, and much more flexible, but some folk just don't want to do it
Must play courses/ must do places - a few name checks is all that's needed